The story of BSC seemed to be one of those wartime secrets that was never to be wholly revealed, like Bletchley Park and the Enigma machine decryptions. But the Enigma story was eventually made public and has been written about since the mid-1970s, with films, TV plays and novels.
Somehow BSC and the role of British agents in the US before Pearl Harbor has remained almost wholly undisclosed. Historians of the British Secret Services know about BSC and its operations, yet despite this book, the world at large remains virtually unaware of it.
The reason is the story of BSC and its operations is embarrassing to the US and remains so today. The document condescending about American gullibility: "The simple truth is the United States is inhabited by people of many conflicting races, interests and creeds. These people, though fully conscious of their wealth and power in the aggregate, are still unsure of themselves individually, still basically on the defensive."
BSC set out to manipulate "these people" and was very successful at so doing - hardly the kind of attitude countries involved in a "special relationship" should display. But that relationship is a myth of course, invented by Churchill after the war, and was been bought into wholesale by every subsequent British prime minister (with the possible exception of Harold Wilson), but certainly including - as some commentators contend - a delusional Tony Blair.
As the secret history of the BSC shows, countries act exclusively to serve their own interests. A commentator in the Washington Post who read the BSC history remarked, "Like many intelligence operations, this one involved exquisite moral ambiguity.
The British used ruthless methods to achieve their goals; by today's peacetime standards, some of the activities may seem outrageous. Yet they were done in the cause of Britain's war against the Nazis - and by pushing America towards intervention, the British spies helped win the war."
Would BSC's activities eventually have led the US to join the war in Europe? The probability is high, as US public opinion was turning towards the end of 1941 - though isolationist sentiments remained influential in certain sectors of government.
BSC's propaganda and relentless news manipulation deserved much of the credit for that change, in the event, matters were taken out of BSC's hands. On the morning of Sunday, December 7 1941 the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor and the question of American neutrality was gone for ever. •
|